{
 "engine": "nil33-lab-validate v1.0",
 "generated": "2026-11-20",
 "note": "These checks measure the model against itself: luck and assumptions. They do not show that the model matches real outcomes.",
 "monteCarlo": [
  {
   "id": "S1",
   "name": "Star quarterback, full-cap program",
   "published": 234224.08,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 236740.0054,
    "sd": 7504.7683,
    "p5": 224625.2218,
    "p50": 236954.8123,
    "p95": 249199.9765,
    "min": 216973.2791,
    "max": 257885.9073
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 2063255.2981,
    "sd": 15293.2709,
    "p5": 2036673.6363,
    "p50": 2063637.6541,
    "p95": 2086194.59,
    "min": 2028941.1965,
    "max": 2111161.7415
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 2299995.3035,
    "sd": 17321.7579,
    "p5": 2270821.1639,
    "p50": 2300905.4214,
    "p95": 2327562.2222,
    "min": 2257076.5202,
    "max": 2354392.3318
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 506788.5321,
    "sd": 15460.5263,
    "p5": 482473.2001,
    "p50": 507337.2501,
    "p95": 532067.6547,
    "min": 450832.5322,
    "max": 549403.1816
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 145038.9879,
    "sd": 6492.9404,
    "p5": 135740.6059,
    "p50": 144472.8796,
    "p95": 156295.9813,
    "min": 129034.3759,
    "max": 161754.2713
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1708,
    "sd": 0.0081,
    "p5": 0.1576,
    "p50": 0.171,
    "p95": 0.184,
    "min": 0.1497,
    "max": 0.195
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S2",
   "name": "Starting football player, full-cap program",
   "published": 13535.78,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 13144.763,
    "sd": 778.7459,
    "p5": 11965.8298,
    "p50": 13172.0804,
    "p95": 14301.8395,
    "min": 11201.5586,
    "max": 15351.1376
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 245512.6621,
    "sd": 1363.9353,
    "p5": 243431.2777,
    "p50": 245513.4349,
    "p95": 247611.9333,
    "min": 241756.0001,
    "max": 249633.2773
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 258657.4252,
    "sd": 1434.5921,
    "p5": 256265.3297,
    "p50": 258553.7387,
    "p95": 261164.2511,
    "min": 255158.2241,
    "max": 262194.248
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 32478.9532,
    "sd": 1703.8125,
    "p5": 29946.1131,
    "p50": 32360.385,
    "p95": 35141.3707,
    "min": 28116.4091,
    "max": 37099.1015
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 9302.8434,
    "sd": 669.7797,
    "p5": 8253.6493,
    "p50": 9257.2213,
    "p95": 10359.6591,
    "min": 7764.339,
    "max": 11125.0375
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1717,
    "sd": 0.0138,
    "p5": 0.1524,
    "p50": 0.1705,
    "p95": 0.1954,
    "min": 0.1325,
    "max": 0.2052
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S3",
   "name": "Depth football player, average paying school",
   "published": 418.52,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 358.5876,
    "sd": 62.6251,
    "p5": 258.3872,
    "p50": 359.4581,
    "p95": 463.5176,
    "min": 222.4281,
    "max": 509.4896
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 8750.3611,
    "sd": 127.7728,
    "p5": 8549.9953,
    "p50": 8744.5896,
    "p95": 8948.2932,
    "min": 8392.9155,
    "max": 9118.7012
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 9108.9487,
    "sd": 145.6125,
    "p5": 8856.6754,
    "p50": 9118.0395,
    "p95": 9359.2119,
    "min": 8767.4554,
    "max": 9481.2902
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 1166.3398,
    "sd": 116.4255,
    "p5": 969.3319,
    "p50": 1171.5672,
    "p95": 1358.614,
    "min": 820.4907,
    "max": 1545.2359
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 331.9656,
    "sd": 46.1242,
    "p5": 262.9349,
    "p50": 331.2754,
    "p95": 411.2505,
    "min": 213.1729,
    "max": 467.1393
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1755,
    "sd": 0.0232,
    "p5": 0.1367,
    "p50": 0.1751,
    "p95": 0.2106,
    "min": 0.1088,
    "max": 0.2703
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S4",
   "name": "Star men's basketball player, full-cap program",
   "published": 243232.7,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 236740.0054,
    "sd": 7504.7683,
    "p5": 224625.2218,
    "p50": 236954.8123,
    "p95": 249199.9765,
    "min": 216973.2791,
    "max": 257885.9073
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 1040855.2981,
    "sd": 15293.2709,
    "p5": 1014273.6362,
    "p50": 1041237.6541,
    "p95": 1063794.59,
    "min": 1006541.1965,
    "max": 1088761.7415
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 1277595.3035,
    "sd": 17321.7579,
    "p5": 1248421.1639,
    "p50": 1278505.4214,
    "p95": 1305162.2222,
    "min": 1234676.5202,
    "max": 1331992.3317
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 506788.5321,
    "sd": 15460.5263,
    "p5": 482473.2001,
    "p50": 507337.2501,
    "p95": 532067.6547,
    "min": 450832.5322,
    "max": 549403.1816
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 145038.9879,
    "sd": 6492.9404,
    "p5": 135740.6059,
    "p50": 144472.8796,
    "p95": 156295.9813,
    "min": 129034.3759,
    "max": 161754.2713
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1708,
    "sd": 0.0081,
    "p5": 0.1576,
    "p50": 0.171,
    "p95": 0.184,
    "min": 0.1497,
    "max": 0.195
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S5",
   "name": "Starting women's basketball player, average school",
   "published": 7359.19,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 7677.7608,
    "sd": 517.535,
    "p5": 6939.8771,
    "p50": 7668.0197,
    "p95": 8593.7723,
    "min": 6263.3028,
    "max": 9017.6826
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 35490.0258,
    "sd": 973.205,
    "p5": 33973.9608,
    "p50": 35456.2909,
    "p95": 37080.1543,
    "min": 33047.2243,
    "max": 38341.3845
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 43167.7865,
    "sd": 1076.4073,
    "p5": 41544.9412,
    "p50": 43098.1083,
    "p95": 45137.141,
    "min": 40786.3908,
    "max": 46871.0685
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 19166.1581,
    "sd": 1027.7672,
    "p5": 17374.8372,
    "p50": 19166.455,
    "p95": 21030.7225,
    "min": 16569.1669,
    "max": 21539.2308
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 5567.038,
    "sd": 379.7567,
    "p5": 4986.0498,
    "p50": 5606.6808,
    "p95": 6211.9056,
    "min": 4608.8044,
    "max": 6427.7011
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1704,
    "sd": 0.0133,
    "p5": 0.1498,
    "p50": 0.1698,
    "p95": 0.1928,
    "min": 0.1385,
    "max": 0.2016
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S6",
   "name": "Rotation Olympic-sport athlete, small pool",
   "published": 519.46,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 510.3305,
    "sd": 56.0513,
    "p5": 416.1936,
    "p50": 516.7761,
    "p95": 591.9229,
    "min": 372.6134,
    "max": 681.4179
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 2942.6364,
    "sd": 125.5917,
    "p5": 2735.7205,
    "p50": 2936.0221,
    "p95": 3145.0164,
    "min": 2675.2585,
    "max": 3332.3905
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 3452.9669,
    "sd": 134.6268,
    "p5": 3236.2977,
    "p50": 3440.4324,
    "p95": 3671.063,
    "min": 3091.0955,
    "max": 3811.9982
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 1472.134,
    "sd": 134.1907,
    "p5": 1280.2396,
    "p50": 1466.7042,
    "p95": 1694.6398,
    "min": 1099.5885,
    "max": 1971.7005
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 410.7106,
    "sd": 47.9021,
    "p5": 335.1702,
    "p50": 406.9735,
    "p95": 486.3492,
    "min": 297.7535,
    "max": 605.1363
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1796,
    "sd": 0.0228,
    "p5": 0.1457,
    "p50": 0.179,
    "p95": 0.2149,
    "min": 0.0964,
    "max": 0.2514
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S7",
   "name": "Starter with a 20% agent, no fee cap",
   "published": 9164.02,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 8732.5038,
    "sd": 696.2223,
    "p5": 7639.1673,
    "p50": 8751.6998,
    "p95": 9914.9329,
    "min": 6810.2833,
    "max": 10686.3936
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 243728.3722,
    "sd": 1336.3499,
    "p5": 241611.6755,
    "p50": 243708.683,
    "p95": 245862.1703,
    "min": 239963.2905,
    "max": 247826.3373
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 252460.876,
    "sd": 1332.7055,
    "p5": 250324.5968,
    "p50": 252313.6627,
    "p95": 254731.722,
    "min": 249291.0506,
    "max": 255683.8796
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 32478.9532,
    "sd": 1703.8125,
    "p5": 29946.1131,
    "p50": 32360.385,
    "p95": 35141.3707,
    "min": 28116.4091,
    "max": 37099.1015
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 9302.8434,
    "sd": 669.7797,
    "p5": 8253.6493,
    "p50": 9257.2213,
    "p95": 10359.6591,
    "min": 7764.339,
    "max": 11125.0375
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1717,
    "sd": 0.0138,
    "p5": 0.1524,
    "p50": 0.1705,
    "p95": 0.1954,
    "min": 0.1325,
    "max": 0.2052
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "S8",
   "name": "Starter with a 20% agent, 5% cap on NIL33",
   "published": 15404.23,
   "seeds": 200,
   "n": 1000,
   "gainPositiveShare": 1,
   "gain": {
    "mean": 14929.0529,
    "sd": 790.7514,
    "p5": 13682.7502,
    "p50": 14965.1223,
    "p95": 16072.2305,
    "min": 13059.3457,
    "max": 17106.7456
   },
   "netToday": {
    "mean": 243728.3722,
    "sd": 1336.3499,
    "p5": 241611.6755,
    "p50": 243708.683,
    "p95": 245862.1703,
    "min": 239963.2905,
    "max": 247826.3373
   },
   "netNil33": {
    "mean": 258657.4252,
    "sd": 1434.5921,
    "p5": 256265.3297,
    "p50": 258553.7387,
    "p95": 261164.2511,
    "min": 255158.2241,
    "max": 262194.248
   },
   "leakToday": {
    "mean": 32478.9532,
    "sd": 1703.8125,
    "p5": 29946.1131,
    "p50": 32360.385,
    "p95": 35141.3707,
    "min": 28116.4091,
    "max": 37099.1015
   },
   "leakNil33": {
    "mean": 9302.8434,
    "sd": 669.7797,
    "p5": 8253.6493,
    "p50": 9257.2213,
    "p95": 10359.6591,
    "min": 7764.339,
    "max": 11125.0375
   },
   "rejectShareToday": {
    "mean": 0.1717,
    "sd": 0.0138,
    "p5": 0.1524,
    "p50": 0.1705,
    "p95": 0.1954,
    "min": 0.1325,
    "max": 0.2052
   }
  }
 ],
 "sensitivity": {
  "id": "S2",
  "name": "Starting football player, full-cap program",
  "move": 0.25,
  "baseGain": 12946.9429,
  "n": 5000,
  "seed": 33,
  "rows": [
   {
    "assumption": "Spread of deal sizes",
    "base": 1,
    "low": 0.75,
    "high": 1.25,
    "gainLow": 10429.5018,
    "gainHigh": 17076.3679,
    "swing": 6646.8661
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Rejection odds for an overpriced deal, both columns",
    "base": 0.85,
    "low": 0.6375,
    "high": 1,
    "gainLow": 10076.1963,
    "gainHigh": 14640.8989,
    "swing": 4564.7026
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Paperwork complete at submission, NIL33",
    "base": 0.95,
    "low": 0.7125,
    "high": 1,
    "gainLow": 9383.1009,
    "gainHigh": 13639.3871,
    "swing": 4256.2861
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Paperwork complete at submission, today",
    "base": 0.6,
    "low": 0.45,
    "high": 0.75,
    "gainLow": 15007.4462,
    "gainHigh": 10812.2718,
    "swing": 4195.1744
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Deals tied to an event date",
    "base": 0.35,
    "low": 0.2625,
    "high": 0.4375,
    "gainLow": 11973.4778,
    "gainHigh": 13813.3082,
    "swing": 1839.8304
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Overpriced deals repriced before submission, NIL33",
    "base": 0.6,
    "low": 0.45,
    "high": 0.75,
    "gainLow": 12258.8928,
    "gainHigh": 13622.5771,
    "swing": 1363.6844
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Cleared but never paid, today",
    "base": 0.04,
    "low": 0.03,
    "high": 0.05,
    "gainLow": 12323.9674,
    "gainHigh": 13493.3277,
    "swing": 1169.3603
   },
   {
    "assumption": "How far above comparables an overpriced deal is",
    "base": 3,
    "low": 2.25,
    "high": 3.75,
    "gainLow": 13370.2109,
    "gainHigh": 12523.4481,
    "swing": 846.7628
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Hidden agent cut odds, today",
    "base": 0.1,
    "low": 0.075,
    "high": 0.125,
    "gainLow": 12867.3823,
    "gainHigh": 13040.7699,
    "swing": 173.3877
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Collective deals priced above comparables",
    "base": 0.15,
    "low": 0.1125,
    "high": 0.1875,
    "gainLow": 12836.1479,
    "gainHigh": 12953.9703,
    "swing": 117.8224
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Introducer dispute odds, today",
    "base": 0.08,
    "low": 0.06,
    "high": 0.1,
    "gainLow": 12902.7882,
    "gainHigh": 12980.4707,
    "swing": 77.6825
   },
   {
    "assumption": "Deals brought by a middleman",
    "base": 0.3,
    "low": 0.225,
    "high": 0.375,
    "gainLow": 12915.4159,
    "gainHigh": 12973.1958,
    "swing": 57.7799
   }
  ],
  "allPositive": true
 },
 "convergence": {
  "id": "S2",
  "name": "Starting football player, full-cap program",
  "rows": [
   {
    "n": 200,
    "seeds": 40,
    "mean": 13106.8565,
    "sd": 1748.0389,
    "p5": 10463.3235,
    "p95": 15902.1393
   },
   {
    "n": 1000,
    "seeds": 40,
    "mean": 13321.1475,
    "sd": 710.1314,
    "p5": 11976.9811,
    "p95": 14311.4404
   },
   {
    "n": 5000,
    "seeds": 40,
    "mean": 13054.0718,
    "sd": 294.22,
    "p5": 12568.4992,
    "p95": 13495.3715
   }
  ]
 },
 "pool": [
  {
   "id": "P1",
   "name": "Full-cap program, 5% above $5,000, equal share",
   "seeds": 60,
   "reps": 4,
   "poolSize": {
    "mean": 506905.4436,
    "sd": 26361.9425,
    "p5": 471957.2269,
    "p50": 505663.2369,
    "p95": 550487.02,
    "min": 438898.6613,
    "max": 564859.0569
   },
   "p10Before": {
    "mean": 608.3577,
    "sd": 16.1123,
    "p5": 597.4196,
    "p50": 597.4196,
    "p95": 639.6696,
    "min": 597.4196,
    "max": 675.6696
   },
   "p10After": {
    "mean": 1632.4091,
    "sd": 56.2812,
    "p5": 1550.8685,
    "p50": 1631.7812,
    "p95": 1730.6059,
    "min": 1484.0836,
    "max": 1764.7994
   },
   "giniBefore": {
    "mean": 0.8349,
    "sd": 0.0026,
    "p5": 0.8311,
    "p50": 0.8351,
    "p95": 0.8393,
    "min": 0.8293,
    "max": 0.8416
   },
   "giniAfter": {
    "mean": 0.8211,
    "sd": 0.0022,
    "p5": 0.8179,
    "p50": 0.8213,
    "p95": 0.8246,
    "min": 0.8163,
    "max": 0.8269
   },
   "worseThanToday": {
    "mean": 0.0611,
    "sd": 0.0053,
    "p5": 0.0525,
    "p50": 0.0616,
    "p95": 0.0682,
    "min": 0.0475,
    "max": 0.0717
   },
   "poolShareOfRailsGain": {
    "mean": 0.3125,
    "sd": 0.0486,
    "p5": 0.2406,
    "p50": 0.3041,
    "p95": 0.4031,
    "min": 0.2137,
    "max": 0.4377
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "P2",
   "name": "Full-cap program, 5% above $5,000, raise the floor",
   "seeds": 60,
   "reps": 4,
   "poolSize": {
    "mean": 506905.4436,
    "sd": 26361.9425,
    "p5": 471957.2269,
    "p50": 505663.2369,
    "p95": 550487.02,
    "min": 438898.6613,
    "max": 564859.0569
   },
   "p10Before": {
    "mean": 608.3577,
    "sd": 16.1123,
    "p5": 597.4196,
    "p50": 597.4196,
    "p95": 639.6696,
    "min": 597.4196,
    "max": 675.6696
   },
   "p10After": {
    "mean": 4102.4069,
    "sd": 130.2189,
    "p5": 3921.7748,
    "p50": 4105.638,
    "p95": 4306.1325,
    "min": 3741.3334,
    "max": 4400.377
   },
   "giniBefore": {
    "mean": 0.8349,
    "sd": 0.0026,
    "p5": 0.8311,
    "p50": 0.8351,
    "p95": 0.8393,
    "min": 0.8293,
    "max": 0.8416
   },
   "giniAfter": {
    "mean": 0.8106,
    "sd": 0.002,
    "p5": 0.8078,
    "p50": 0.8106,
    "p95": 0.8139,
    "min": 0.8061,
    "max": 0.8162
   },
   "worseThanToday": {
    "mean": 0.1916,
    "sd": 0.0083,
    "p5": 0.1758,
    "p50": 0.1919,
    "p95": 0.2025,
    "min": 0.1692,
    "max": 0.2152
   },
   "poolShareOfRailsGain": {
    "mean": 0.3125,
    "sd": 0.0486,
    "p5": 0.2406,
    "p50": 0.3041,
    "p95": 0.4031,
    "min": 0.2137,
    "max": 0.4377
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "P3",
   "name": "Full-cap program, 5% above $5,000, by need",
   "seeds": 60,
   "reps": 4,
   "poolSize": {
    "mean": 506905.4436,
    "sd": 26361.9425,
    "p5": 471957.2269,
    "p50": 505663.2369,
    "p95": 550487.02,
    "min": 438898.6613,
    "max": 564859.0569
   },
   "p10Before": {
    "mean": 608.3577,
    "sd": 16.1123,
    "p5": 597.4196,
    "p50": 597.4196,
    "p95": 639.6696,
    "min": 597.4196,
    "max": 675.6696
   },
   "p10After": {
    "mean": 3411.3492,
    "sd": 153.022,
    "p5": 3167.821,
    "p50": 3397.9629,
    "p95": 3649.8711,
    "min": 2999.0515,
    "max": 3757.2322
   },
   "giniBefore": {
    "mean": 0.8349,
    "sd": 0.0026,
    "p5": 0.8311,
    "p50": 0.8351,
    "p95": 0.8393,
    "min": 0.8293,
    "max": 0.8416
   },
   "giniAfter": {
    "mean": 0.8118,
    "sd": 0.002,
    "p5": 0.8091,
    "p50": 0.8118,
    "p95": 0.815,
    "min": 0.8075,
    "max": 0.8172
   },
   "worseThanToday": {
    "mean": 0.1892,
    "sd": 0.0081,
    "p5": 0.1732,
    "p50": 0.1899,
    "p95": 0.2005,
    "min": 0.1657,
    "max": 0.2126
   },
   "poolShareOfRailsGain": {
    "mean": 0.3125,
    "sd": 0.0486,
    "p5": 0.2406,
    "p50": 0.3041,
    "p95": 0.4031,
    "min": 0.2137,
    "max": 0.4377
   }
  }
 ]
}
